- Video of J3 Praxis Cafe, 2014.
- Productive Margins at Utopia Festival, Somerset House, June 2016.
- Cohen, S., McDermont, M. Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold – new theorisations on regulating for engagement, Paper for the Connected Communities Symposium on Social Justice and Co-produced Research.
- Ersoy, A. Coregulation as a form of new planning policy, Paper for the UK-Ireland Planning Research Conference.
- Ersoy, A. Co-producing Resilience: Beneath the City, Co-exist? Paper for the Policy and Politics Conference.
- Ersoy, A. (2014) What does regulation mean for Cohesion Policy Paper for the European Union Committee of Regions Conference.
- Facer, K., Larner, W., Leggett, M. (2014) What counts? Valuing co-designed research across different disciplines, Paper for the 6th Living Knowledge Conference, Copenhagen, 9-11 April, 2014.
- Larner, W. Gendering Co-Production Paper for the Social Politics 20th Anniversary Conference: Crossing Borders 2: Revisioning Gender: Complex Inequalities and Global Dimensions.
- McDermont, M. From the edge to centre stage: the role of intermediary community organisations in regulating for engagement, Paper for the Annual meeting of the Canadian and Australia and New Zealand Law and Society Associations.
- Thomas G ‘It’s just a normal place’: how young people imagine, negotiate and resist the stigmatisation of a post-industrial community, Paper for the ESHMS 3rd Special Interest Meeting: Europe in a Global Perspective. Norwegian University of Science and Technology, 3 September.
- Thomas G (2015) Sticky reputations: young peoples’ negotiation of stigma and place in a post-industrial community, Paper for American Sociological Association Annual Meeting. Chicago Hilton, Illinois, 24 August 2015.
- Thomas G (2015) Having a hard(d) time? Young peoples’ experiences of safety, regulation, and place in a marginalised South Wales community, Paper for Pacific Sociology Association Annual Conference. Hyatt Regency Long Beach, California, 4 April 2015.
- Conference presentation: Researching Co-production, 2014.
- Sales, A. Productive Margins Forum 1, Working Paper.
- Byrne, E. Productive Margins Forum 2, Working Paper.
- Various authors Productive Margins Forum 3, Working Paper.
- Various authors Productive Margins Forum 4, Working Paper.
- Noorani, T. Productive Margins: Regulating for Engagement Scoping Study: Phase 2, Working Paper.
- Noorani, T. Productive Margins: Regulating for Engagement Scoping Study: Phase 1, Working Paper.
- Noorani, T. (2014) The 7 Non-Senses of Co-Production, Working Paper. See notes.
- Presentation: What does regulation mean for cohesion policy 2014-20? Building partnerships under the new arrangements, European Union Committee of Regions conference, 2014.
- Including and strengthening the education amendments in the ‘Violence Against Women, Domestic Abuse and Sexual Violence’ bill response to National Consultation 2015.
- Matthew Olden (2013) Where the ocean meets the shore along the marginal way .., 2013. Productive Marginals is a series of real and meta computer characters who respond to the Productive Margins archive. Read blog post
- Joff Winterhart’s Artistic jotting for third Productive Margins Forum, October 2013, Knowle West Media Centre . View full report with jottings.
- Joff Winterhart’s Artistic jotting for Praxis Cafe‘ –Fixing it yourselves, women activists in Knowle West, KWMC, Bristol, 2014.
- Sticker Installation, 2014
- Postcards–Productive Margins research strands, Connected Communities showcase, 2014.
- Dance walking performance Bodies in Flight, Connected Communities showcase, 2014.
- GIS wayfinding exercise, 2014.
- Spaces of dissent, Faculty of Social Sciences and Law, Thinking Futures Programme 2013, UOB, Mshed. See program.
- PRAXIS CAFÉ–RESISTANCE IN THE CITY AND THE MOVING IMAGE– Hamilton House, Bristol, 2014.
- PRAXIS CAFÉ- FIXING IT OURSELVES-WOMEN ACTIVISTS IN KNOWLE WEST, Bristol, 2014.
- PRAXIS CAFÉ- Junction 3 Market,Bristol Food Connections Festival, Easton, Bristol, 2014.
- Praxis Café at SPAN A Change is Going to Come? – Film, Food and Reflection, Easton, Bristol, 2014.
- Praxis Café – Connecting Histories of Dissent to Present-day Resistance, AHRC Connected Communities Showcase, Bristol, 2014.
- Praxis Café – Transforming Spaces: Productive Resistance, AHRC Connected Communities Showcase, 2014.
- The Joined-up University? New Encounters between universities, their partners and publics, IAS seminar series, University of Bristol, 2013.
- Girls Making History Workshops x 11: – Introduction-Skills Audit, Blogging and Social Media,- Personas, Relationships and Perception- Audience and 3D Printing-Feminism 101 and Confidence-Dissent, Gender and Branding- Desirable Jewellery-DVA and the Law-Design Fiction Challenge-Healthy Relationship Game Design-Game Post-production, Bristol, 2013.
- Nik Theodore(2015) Subject Spaces: On the Ethics of Coproducing Urban Research IAS Lecture Listen to audio Recording.
Connected Communities: Cultures of Dissent: A Festival of Productive Margins, 2014. See program.
- Praxis cafe
- Lost and Found GIS workshop
Mapping, making and mobilising in Merthyr
- Listen to members of the 4Ms project talk in-situ about the challenges and affordances of using creative and affective methodologies with young people living in economically marginalized post-industrial places for SAGE Video Research Methods mater series on “Participatory Research: Creative Methods”.
Professor Gabrielle Ivinson talks about how academics, artists and young people entangle with the transformative potentialities of creative methodologies that demand a process of ‘un-knowing’. She draws out some of the micro-moments in the workshops that formed the series of installations and film in the exhibition ‘Graphic Moves’.
Professor Emma Renold talks about the “Relationships Matters” case study and the unexpected twists and turns in using creative methodologies to explore teen girls’ experiences of sexual safety and violence. She maps the journey of how data becomes da(r)ta to produce artefacts, crafted from experience, that ripple through and affect peer cultures, school assemblies and national policy landscapes (see Renold forthcoming).
- Watch footage from the Feminist Posthumanism and New Materialisam Research Methodologies conference and workshops. This short documentary about the day, features clips and reflections from the 3 hour workshop, led by Gabrielle Ivinson and Emma Renold, that was designed to demonstrate the affective power of projected moving images how this method stimulates and generates unexpected and emergent issue specifically around bodies and landscape. https://vimeo.com/140407753
- Thomas, G. M. (2016) ‘It’s not that bad’: stigma, health, and place in a post-industrial community. Health & Place 38, pp. 1-7.
- Renold, Emma (forthcoming 2017) “Feel what I Feel”: Creating d(a)rta with teen girls to make sexual violence matter, Journal of Gender Studies,
- Thomas, G.M., Renold, E. et al. (in progress) Dark matters: the impact of street lighting on young people’s sense of safety in post-industrial places, <journal to be decided>
Presentations and workshops
- June 2016. (Renold) When data becomes da(r)ta: an onto-cartography of teen girls, sexual violence and creative activism, Gender and Education Bi-Annual Conference, University of Linkoping, Sweden, 14-17 June 2016.
- June 2016. (Renold) How the ‘ruler skirt’ came to matter and other creative activisms addressing teen sexual violence, in keynote panel ‘Feminist activisms, public engagement and impact in Education’, Gender and Education Bi-Annual Conference, University of Linkoping, Sweden, 14-17 June 2016.
- June 2016, (Renold) The Wales Agenda: engaging creative and affective methodologies with young people to address gender and sexual violence. 2 day invited international Sex Education symposia, Norrköping, June 13-14
- May 2016 (Ivinson and Renold) Graphic Moves: attuning to the materialities of arts based practices as a basis for social resistance, The Twelfth International Congress of Qualitative Inquiry, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, May 18-21, 2016.
- February 2016 (Ivinson, Renold and Thomas) Counteracting pathologising discourses of poverty and creating radical pedagogies, invited symposia, Challenging Deficity Models of Poverty, British Education Research Association, (BERA) Poverty and Policy Advocacy Research Commission, 15 February 2016.
- June, 2016 ( Ivinson) Making, Mapping and Mobilising in Merthyr: using visual and creative methods to engage change with young people, Sheffield University Student Conference
- September 2015: (Renold, Ivinson, Elliot and Thomas) Graphic Moves: Artful, aleatory and posthuman methodologies in creative research with young people, for Symposium, ‘Leaning to be affected: Mapping young people’s more than human relations’, RGS-IBG Annual International Conference, University of Exeter.
- September 2015: (Thomas) ‘It’s just a normal place’: how young people imagine, negotiate and resist the stigmatisation of a post-industrial community. ESHMS 3rd Special Interest Meeting: Europe in a Global Perspective, Norwegian University of Science and Technology.
- August 2015: Sticky reputations: young peoples’ negotiation of stigma and place in a post-industrial community. American Sociological Association Annual Meeting. Chicago Hilton, Illinois.
- June 2015: (Ivinson and Renold) “Light Moves and Graphic Moves: artful intra-ventions in co-produced participatory research with young people” in Symposium: “Beyond representation: engaging creative and affective methodologies for re-imagining girlhood in place, history and time” for the Gender and Education bi-annual conference.
- June 2015: (Elliott, Byrne, Thomas, Renold, and Ivinson) ‘Creating mobilisation: making participatory arts-based methodologies matter in place-based research’ WISERD Annual Conference (Panel Session). Cardiff Millennium Stadium
- May 2015 (Ivinson and Renold) Graphic Moves: attuning to the materialities of arts based practices as a basis for social resistance. ICQI University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Chicago, Illinois.
- April 2015. Having a hard(d) time? Young peoples’ experiences of safety, regulation, and place in a marginalised South Wales community. Pacific Sociology Association Annual Conference. Hyatt Regency Long Beach, California.
- March 2015, (Renold) Keynote, Research more-then-human assemblages: working with creative and affective methodologies in researching teen girls, Utrecht Univeristy, 5 March 2015
- March 2015 (Renold and Young people), Making Healthy Relationships Matter, invited address, Welsh Women’s Aid National Conference, Cardiff City Hall, 27th March 2016. http://avow.org/en/news/welsh-womens-aid-conference-2015
- December 2015 (Renold) The STARTER Project: how to work with young people to creatively and safely address sexual violence in schools, Keeping Learner’s Safe: Everybody’s Business, 3rd December, Welsh Government conference. More information. Delivered to over 100 educational practitioners and policy makers, this workshop featured the case study from the Relationship Matters project on how young people can creatively and safely promote gender equalities for respectful relationships. The middle section of the Graphic Moves (“words won’t pin me down” was also shown, alongside the ruler skirt and the tagged heart, see publications).
- October 2015, (Renold) Relationship Matters: Using Arts-based Methods to Address Sexual Harassment in Schools and Communities, Giving Girls a Fair Chance: International Day of the Girl conference, Mercure Holland House Hotel in central Cardiff on Friday 9th October. http://www.fullcircleeducation.org/girls-conference-2015/ See the storify of the day here: https://storify.com/FullCircle1/giving-girls-a-fair-chance This presentation and workshop was delivered to over 40 practitioners. Through film, poems, and other artefacts, and drawing upon the “Relationship Matters” activist-engagement project I explored how creative methods can be used with young people to support them in raising awareness of sexual harassment in schools and communities.
- July 2015: Ivinson, Renold and Angharad, led a 3 hour workshop, “Moving with Affective Methodologies”, for Provocations, Improvisations: Encounters between Art, Sciences & Qualitative Research At the 4th Summer Institute in Qualitative Research, 2015 Manchester Metropolitan University (MMU), Education & Social Research Institute (ESRI), Monday 6th July – Friday 10th July. Inspired by the work of Erin Manning we offer two films: “Light Moves” and “Dance of the not-yet”. Each film enables us to glimpse how the body, entangled in objects, landscape, movement and light align, interact and call our participants and us into the world. Led by Jên Anghared, the workshop then opens up to encourage participants to think with the body and affect, and how ‘movement moves’ and composes us.
- June 2015 (Elliott, Byrne, Ivinson, Thomas – also Richard Davies [filmmaker], Nicola Ebdon [filmmaker], Heloise-Godfrey Talbot [artists], Seth Oliver [artist], and Rowan Talbot [artist]) Merthyr moves: an artistic celebration of life in the Welsh Valleys. Connected Communities Festival. Cardiff UK.
- June 2015 (Ivinson and Renold) Projecting Life, for “Feminist Posthumanism and New Materialism Research Methodologies in Education” (Emma Renold, Cardiff University, Jessica Ringrose, IoE, and Anna Hickey-Moody, Goldsmiths, Jayne Osgood, Middlesex University), 11-12 June, 2015. This 3 hour workshop was designed to demonstrate the affective power of moving images that are multiply projected and how this method stimulates and generates unexpected and emergent issue specifically around bodies and landscape. https://vimeo.com/140407753
Zebras Campaign for better street lighting Read about young people’s creative activism in fighting for better street lighting and safer routes in their local community Young People, GIS Mapping, and Zebras
Relationship Matters Campaign for better healthy relationships education.
Read young people’s story about how the ‘Relationship Matters’ campaign informed national policy and continues to impact upon practitioners and policy makers through artefacts.
Their case study also features in the Welsh Government’s “Good practice guide: a whole education approach to violence against women, domestic abuse and sexual violence”.
Key members of the group have also been involved in co-producing the forthcoming, ‘AGENDA: A young people’s guide to making positive relationships matter’ (to be launched at the Pierhead Cardiff Bay on 30 November 2016).
See some of the artwork created by young people from the Relationship Matters project.
In 2014, Courtney, Katie, Renee and Shonice from the Forsythia Youth Centre and pupils from St Aloysius Primary School in North Merthyr, Wales created a film to speak back to numerous press and media reports that stigmatised the post-industrial locality where the young people are growing up. This film, ‘Light Moves’, stunningly captures the vibrancy of moving bodies in space. Light Moves also became a catalyst for inspiring artistic responses to a GCSE art examination question about ‘Connections’ in a local school.
In 2015, the team came together again to work on a series of arts-based workshops: Mashing Up The Land’ , ‘Projections’ and ‘Found Sounds and Street Beats’ , young people created a wide range of artefacts, stories, soundscapes and moving images that became part of the co-produced film “Graphic Moves”.
The film includes a selection of art work and poetry from girls who created artistic ways to communicate and express issues around sexual violence. The film also speaks back to the pathologising images of North Merthyr that appeared in the BBC documentary SKINT and allowed the young people to reclaim and publically display images of the post industrial place where they are growing up.
This 3 minute short film features movement artist Jên Angharad as she swings through the exhibition of Graphic Moves at The Riverfront in Newport (5 June – 28 June 2015).
For more on the making of the workshops, exhibitions and artworks, follow #mmmm as the team communicate forthcoming and recent academic and creative outputs.
The 4Ms project has participated in and/or hosted the following community events.
Global Girls, Manchester, 13 May 2016
Light Moves and Graphic Moves will be shown at the international event ‘Global Girls. This event brings together an interdisciplinary team of leading researchers, activists and community organizers who share an interest in how being a girl and a woman is constructed across spaces, places and cultures.
- Graphic Moves exhibition, Riverfront Art Centre, Newport, 2015 (pictures available here)
- Graphic Moves exhibition with Dance Performance, Merthyr Tydfil, 2015
- Graphic Moves exhibition, Red House/Theatr Soar, Merthyr Tydfil, 2015 (pictures available here and here)
- Graphic Moves exhibitions, Abacus Art Gallery, Cardiff, 2015
- Cardiff University Engagement Project (Strong People, Healthier Places), Cardiff, 2015
- Theatre Soar and Red House, Merthyr Tydfil, 2015
- Connected Communities Festival, Cardiff, 2015
- Citizens Cymru Assembly, Merthyr Tydfil, 2015
- Citizens Cymru Founding Youth Assembly, Cardiff, 2015
- Citizens UK Training Programme for Local Community Organisers, Cardiff, 2015
- Connected Communities Festival, Cardiff, 2014
- Citizens UK Training Programme (Gareth Thomas), Leicester, 2014
Regulation of food habits
Policy Brief launch, 21st January, 2015 Junction 3 library, Easton, Bristol.
Harnessing digital space studentship
Isolation and loneliness of older people
Mobilising neighbourhoods studentship
Spaces of dissent studentship
Talk: Who has the right to be a dissenting citizen? Bristol, 2013.
Life chances: low-income families in modern urban settings
Life Chances Project at the Utopia Festival, Somerset House, London June 2016. Provides a good overview of the project.
Talk: Is it easier for some people to have their voice heard than it is for others? Bristol, 2013.
Muslim engagement in Bristol
What do you see?
What do you see?’ is a short film that gives insight into Bristol Muslim women’s visions of the public spaces of the future, including City Hall, a mosque, a market square, the Houses of Parliament and the United Nations.
The premier at the Watershed cinema, Bristol was followed by a panel discussion with the director, the two researchers and the women who feature in the film. Watch video of panel discussion
The following videos were developed for the Connected Communities Festival in 2015.
Lewicki, Aleksandra, Therese O’Toole and Tariq Modood (2014) Building the Bridge: Muslim Community Engagement in Bristol, Research Report, Bristol: Centre for the Study of Ethnicity and Citizenship, University of Bristol. See full report (PDF, 1.8 MB).
Aleksandra Lewicki & Therese O’Toole (2017) Acts and practices of citizenship: Muslim women’s activism in the UK, Ethnic and Racial Studies. See full report
Aabe N et al (2015) Enhancing Spaces for Muslim Women’s Engagement, Policy Briefing (PDF, 1MB).
Productive Margins Collective(2015) Recognising your potential, 6 Policy workshops, Bristol. Download workshop template (PDF, 454 kB).
David & Jones Paper City, 2015 .
Enhancing Muslim engagement in local democratic governance, Thinking Futures: The University of Bristol’s Festival of Social Sciences and Law, 2012. View day program.
Productive Spaces of Muslim Women’s Engagement in Bristol
Inspiring Muslim Women, 23 September 2014, University of Bristol. See article.
Enhancing Muslim Women’s Participation, 8 pilot workshops, 2014, Bristol.